StockedWaters

Herkimer County Fish Stocking Schedule

59 stocked lakes, ponds & streams across Herkimer County, New York — 1,060 dated planting events on record, cited to New York fish & wildlife agency.

Source: New York fish & wildlife agency· updated 2026-05
59
Stocked waters
1,060
Planting records
8
Species
May 2026
Last stocked

Recently stocked in Herkimer County

All New York recent plants →

Lakes and streams in Herkimer County with the freshest stocking activity on file.

All stocked waters in Herkimer County

Ranked by recorded planting frequency. Click any waterbody for its complete stocking history, seasonal calendar, species breakdown, and interactive pin map.

Fourth Lake

Herkimer County · 3 species · 68 records

Last stocked May 2025

Bear Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 55 records

Last stocked September 2025

Third Lake

Herkimer County · 3 species · 45 records

Last stocked May 2026

Raquette Lake

Herkimer County · 2 species · 37 records

Last stocked May 2025

Buck Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 33 records

Last stocked September 2024

South Pond

Herkimer County · 2 species · 30 records

Last stocked September 2025

South Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 28 records

Last stocked September 2025

North Lake

Herkimer County · 3 species · 28 records

Last stocked May 2024

Spruce Creek

Herkimer County · 1 species · 26 records

Last stocked April 2026

Big Moose Lake

Herkimer County · 2 species · 26 records

Last stocked April 2025

Unadilla River

Herkimer County · 1 species · 25 records

Last stocked April 2026

Wolf Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 24 records

Last stocked September 2025

First Lake

Herkimer County · 3 species · 24 records

Last stocked October 2021

Fulmer Creek

Herkimer County · 2 species · 23 records

Last stocked April 2023

Beardsley Lake

Herkimer County · 3 species · 22 records

Last stocked April 2025

Little Rock Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 20 records

Last stocked September 2025

Prospect Reservoir

Herkimer County · 2 species · 18 records

Last stocked April 2025

Old Forge Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 18 records

Last stocked April 2026

Nicks Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 15 records

Last stocked May 2026

Quiver Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked April 2026

Little Salmon Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked September 2025

Razorback Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked September 2025

Md Settlement Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked September 2025

Middle Branch Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked September 2025

Brewer Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked September 2025

Independence Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records

Last stocked September 2024

Sunday Creek

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked May 2026

Bubb Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked September 2025

Lyon Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked September 2025

Evergreen Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked September 2025

Peaked Mountain Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked September 2025

West Lake(aka Sis)

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked September 2025

Hidden Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records

Last stocked September 2025

Stillwater Reservoir

Herkimer County · 1 species · 12 records

Last stocked May 2025

Upper Okara Pond

Herkimer County · 2 species · 12 records

Last stocked May 2023

Steele Creek

Herkimer County · 1 species · 12 records

Last stocked April 2021

Hawk Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 11 records

Last stocked September 2024

Tied Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 11 records

Last stocked October 2022

Cage Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 11 records

Last stocked October 2022

Moss Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records

Last stocked May 2024

Witchhopple Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records

Last stocked May 2025

Salmon Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records

Last stocked May 2025

Negro Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records

Last stocked May 2025

Ransom Brook

Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records

Last stocked April 2020

Third Lake Creek

Herkimer County · 1 species · 8 records

Last stocked April 2019

Little Evergreen Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records

Last stocked September 2025

Sunshine Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records

Last stocked September 2024

Gibbs Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records

Last stocked October 2019

Moyer Creek

Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records

Last stocked April 2017

Higby Twin Pond East

Herkimer County · 1 species · 6 records

Last stocked September 2025

Higby Twin Pond West

Herkimer County · 1 species · 6 records

Last stocked September 2025

Lower Okara Pond

Herkimer County · 1 species · 5 records

Last stocked May 2015

Middle Branch Moose River

Herkimer County · 1 species · 3 records

Last stocked May 2022

Big Moose lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 2 records

Last stocked May 2024

Moshier Reservoir

Herkimer County · 1 species · 2 records

Last stocked September 2012

twitchell lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records

Last stocked October 2025

Fourth lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records

Last stocked October 2025

West Higby Twin

Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records

Last stocked October 2019

Woodhull Lake

Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records

Last stocked October 2017

Species stocked in Herkimer County

Stocked species in Herkimer County

Number of Herkimer County waters on record for each species (a water can hold several).

Frequently asked

What lakes and rivers are stocked in Herkimer County, New York?

Herkimer County has 59 public waters with verified stocking records on file, per New York fish & wildlife agency open data.

What fish species are stocked in Herkimer County?

Commonly stocked fish in Herkimer County include Brook Trout, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout, among 8 total species recorded across county waters.

Which water was stocked most recently in Herkimer County?

Third Lake has the most recent recorded stocking event in Herkimer County (2026-05), per New York fish & wildlife agency.

Do you need a fishing license in Herkimer County, New York?

Yes, all anglers age 16 and older generally need a valid New York freshwater fishing license when fishing in Herkimer County public waters. Always verify current district bag limits and seasonal rules with NY DEC.