Herkimer County Fish Stocking Schedule
59 stocked lakes, ponds & streams across Herkimer County, New York — 1,060 dated planting events on record, cited to New York fish & wildlife agency.
Recently stocked in Herkimer County
All New York recent plants →Lakes and streams in Herkimer County with the freshest stocking activity on file.
Third Lake
Herkimer County · 3 species · 45 records
Last stocked May 2026
Nicks Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 15 records
Last stocked May 2026
Sunday Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked May 2026
Spruce Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 26 records
Last stocked April 2026
Unadilla River
Herkimer County · 1 species · 25 records
Last stocked April 2026
Old Forge Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 18 records
Last stocked April 2026
All stocked waters in Herkimer County
Ranked by recorded planting frequency. Click any waterbody for its complete stocking history, seasonal calendar, species breakdown, and interactive pin map.
Fourth Lake
Herkimer County · 3 species · 68 records
Last stocked May 2025
Bear Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 55 records
Last stocked September 2025
Third Lake
Herkimer County · 3 species · 45 records
Last stocked May 2026
Raquette Lake
Herkimer County · 2 species · 37 records
Last stocked May 2025
Buck Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 33 records
Last stocked September 2024
South Pond
Herkimer County · 2 species · 30 records
Last stocked September 2025
South Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 28 records
Last stocked September 2025
North Lake
Herkimer County · 3 species · 28 records
Last stocked May 2024
Spruce Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 26 records
Last stocked April 2026
Big Moose Lake
Herkimer County · 2 species · 26 records
Last stocked April 2025
Unadilla River
Herkimer County · 1 species · 25 records
Last stocked April 2026
Wolf Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 24 records
Last stocked September 2025
First Lake
Herkimer County · 3 species · 24 records
Last stocked October 2021
Fulmer Creek
Herkimer County · 2 species · 23 records
Last stocked April 2023
Beardsley Lake
Herkimer County · 3 species · 22 records
Last stocked April 2025
Little Rock Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 20 records
Last stocked September 2025
Prospect Reservoir
Herkimer County · 2 species · 18 records
Last stocked April 2025
Old Forge Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 18 records
Last stocked April 2026
Nicks Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 15 records
Last stocked May 2026
Quiver Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked April 2026
Little Salmon Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked September 2025
Razorback Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked September 2025
Md Settlement Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked September 2025
Middle Branch Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked September 2025
Brewer Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked September 2025
Independence Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 14 records
Last stocked September 2024
Sunday Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked May 2026
Bubb Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked September 2025
Lyon Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked September 2025
Evergreen Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked September 2025
Peaked Mountain Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked September 2025
West Lake(aka Sis)
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked September 2025
Hidden Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 13 records
Last stocked September 2025
Stillwater Reservoir
Herkimer County · 1 species · 12 records
Last stocked May 2025
Upper Okara Pond
Herkimer County · 2 species · 12 records
Last stocked May 2023
Steele Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 12 records
Last stocked April 2021
Hawk Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 11 records
Last stocked September 2024
Tied Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 11 records
Last stocked October 2022
Cage Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 11 records
Last stocked October 2022
Moss Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records
Last stocked May 2024
Witchhopple Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records
Last stocked May 2025
Salmon Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records
Last stocked May 2025
Negro Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records
Last stocked May 2025
Ransom Brook
Herkimer County · 1 species · 9 records
Last stocked April 2020
Third Lake Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 8 records
Last stocked April 2019
Little Evergreen Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records
Last stocked September 2025
Sunshine Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records
Last stocked September 2024
Gibbs Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records
Last stocked October 2019
Moyer Creek
Herkimer County · 1 species · 7 records
Last stocked April 2017
Higby Twin Pond East
Herkimer County · 1 species · 6 records
Last stocked September 2025
Higby Twin Pond West
Herkimer County · 1 species · 6 records
Last stocked September 2025
Lower Okara Pond
Herkimer County · 1 species · 5 records
Last stocked May 2015
Middle Branch Moose River
Herkimer County · 1 species · 3 records
Last stocked May 2022
Big Moose lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 2 records
Last stocked May 2024
Moshier Reservoir
Herkimer County · 1 species · 2 records
Last stocked September 2012
twitchell lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records
Last stocked October 2025
Fourth lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records
Last stocked October 2025
West Higby Twin
Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records
Last stocked October 2019
Woodhull Lake
Herkimer County · 1 species · 1 records
Last stocked October 2017
Species stocked in Herkimer County
Stocked species in Herkimer County
Number of Herkimer County waters on record for each species (a water can hold several).
Frequently asked
What lakes and rivers are stocked in Herkimer County, New York?
Herkimer County has 59 public waters with verified stocking records on file, per New York fish & wildlife agency open data.
What fish species are stocked in Herkimer County?
Commonly stocked fish in Herkimer County include Brook Trout, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout, among 8 total species recorded across county waters.
Which water was stocked most recently in Herkimer County?
Third Lake has the most recent recorded stocking event in Herkimer County (2026-05), per New York fish & wildlife agency.
Do you need a fishing license in Herkimer County, New York?
Yes, all anglers age 16 and older generally need a valid New York freshwater fishing license when fishing in Herkimer County public waters. Always verify current district bag limits and seasonal rules with NY DEC.
