StockedWaters

Butterfield Lake Fish Stocking

Jefferson County, New York · 2011–2025 on record

Source: New York fish & wildlife agency· updated 2025-05

According to New York fish & wildlife agency, Butterfield Lake was last stocked May 2025 with Walleye (3,020,000 fish). Butterfield Lake has 15 stocking records on file, spanning 2011–2025, with about 45,036,660 fish stocked over that period.

May 2025
Last stocked
45,036,660
Fish stocked
1
Species
15
Stocking records

When Butterfield Lake is stocked

Butterfield Lake is typically stocked in spring, most often in May — 10 stocking events in that peak month.

Seasonal Stocking Distribution

15 recorded plantings spread across calendar months.

Peak month (May)Standard Season
View accessible data table ↓
Monthly stocking frequency breakdown
MonthStocking Events
January0
February0
March0
April5
May10
June0
July0
August0
September0
October0
November0
December0
How Butterfield Lake's stockings spread across the calendar year.

Stocked Fish Size & Maturity Scale

Biological size distribution reported by agency hatchery loading records.

Avg: 0.4 inches
0" Fry8" catchable20"+

By species

Species profiles

Angler's Field Guide

Fishing Tips & Stocking Guide for Butterfield Lake

Practical advice on fish behavior, recommended tackle, and state regulations for anglers fishing in Jefferson County, New York.

Post-Plant Behavior & Timing

Hatchery-raised fish are conditioned to pelleted feed and open raceways. Following a release into Butterfield Lake, they typically congregate in schools near public access points, boat ramps, or inlets for the first 24 to 48 hours while adjusting to natural water conditions.

Since Butterfield Lake was last stocked May 2025, anglers visiting within 1 to 2 weeks of a reported event generally experience the highest activity before fish disperse into deeper cover.

State Regulations & Licensing

  • •Fishing License: A valid New York freshwater fishing license is required for anglers age 16 and older.Purchase New York license online →
  • •Official Rules & Limits: Bag limits, bait restrictions, and seasonal boundaries are set by New York fish & wildlife agency.Official New York regulations guidebook →
  • •Ethical Conservation: Use barbless hooks and keep fish submerged in water during unhooking.

Recommended Tackle & Presentations

Techniques tailored to the species stocked in Butterfield Lake:

Bass & Panfish Approach

Target visible structure such as docks, weed lines, and fallen trees. Small 1/32 to 1/16 oz jig heads with soft plastic grubs or live worms under a float work well for crappie and bluegill; soft plastic worms or spinnerbaits work well for bass.

Walleye Profile Tips →

Highly regarded as table fare; typically targeted with jigs, live bait rigs, or trolled crankbaits, often after dark.

Rig diagrams for stocked lakes →How long after stocking fish start biting →

Gear & Tackle

Recommended Tackle for Butterfield Lake

Field-tested tackle and presentations matched to the species stocked here.

Proven Bass StapleYamamoto

Gary Yamamoto 5-inch Custom Senko Stickbaits

The heavy salt-impregnated plastic produces a unique horizontal shimmy on the fall around weed beds, docks, and submerged timber.

Top Panfish ProducerBobby Garland

Bobby Garland Baby Shad Crappie Jig & Plastic Kit

Micro-jig heads paired with soft swimbaits mimic tiny baitfish and insects for schooling crappie and bluegill.

Essential Angler ToolKastKing

Aluminum Fishing Pliers with Braid Cutters

Safely removes hooks, pinches split-shot sinkers, and cleanly snips braided, mono, and fluorocarbon lines.

Gear OrganizationPlano

Plano Waterproof Utility Tackle Box Tray (3600)

Keeps terminal tackle, weights, and spinners dry and corrosion-free with customizable compartments.

As an Amazon Associate, StockedWaters earns from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Recommendations are chosen for hatchery-conditioned fish behavior and ethical rigging. We may receive a referral commission if you buy through these links. Read our editorial policy & standards.

Nearby stocked waters

Other stocked waters near Butterfield Lake, freshest activity first.

Nearby waters by direction

Stocked waters around Butterfield Lake, by compass bearing and straight-line distance (rings every 15 mi).

15 within 60 mi
15 mi30 mi45 mi60 miNSWEMillsite Lake — 2 miLake of the Woods — 2 miLake of The Woods — 2 miSixberry Lake — 3 miGrass Lake — 3 miRed Lake — 4 miMoon Lake — 5 miHyde Lake — 6 miGrass River South Branch — 8 miYellow Lake — 9 miSylvia Lake — 18 miLake Sylvia — 18 miQuarry Pond — 20 miFelts Mills Creek — 20 miBonaparte Lake — 22 mi
2 mi awayJefferson County

Millsite Lake

Last stocked November 2025
2 species · 33 records
Open waterbody page →

Stocking history

Most recent stockings first. Dates shown at the precision the agency reported.

Stocking records
DateSpeciesNumberSizeSource
May 2025Walleye3,020,0000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
April 2024Walleye3,020,0000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
April 2023Walleye3,020,0000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
April 2022Walleye3,020,0000.5"New York fish & wildlife agency
April 2021Walleye3,020,0000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2020Walleye3,680,7800.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2019Walleye3,020,0000.5"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2018Walleye3,020,0000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
Show 7 more stocking records →
Earlier stocking records
DateSpeciesNumberSizeSource
May 2017Walleye3,020,0000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2016Walleye2,446,2000.3"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2015Walleye2,669,6800.4"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2014Walleye3,020,0000.4"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2013Walleye3,020,0000.4"New York fish & wildlife agency
April 2012Walleye3,020,0000.4"New York fish & wildlife agency
May 2011Walleye3,020,0000.4"New York fish & wildlife agency

Frequently asked

When was Butterfield Lake last stocked?

According to New York fish & wildlife agency, Butterfield Lake was last stocked May 2025 with Walleye (3,020,000 fish).

What fish species are stocked in Butterfield Lake?

Butterfield Lake is stocked with Walleye.

What time of year is Butterfield Lake stocked?

Butterfield Lake is typically stocked in spring, most often in May.

How often is Butterfield Lake stocked?

Butterfield Lake is stocked intermittently — 15 recorded stockings between 2011 and 2025.

How many fish have been stocked in Butterfield Lake?

About 45,036,660 fish have been stocked in Butterfield Lake across 15 recorded events since 2011, per New York fish & wildlife agency.

What size are the fish stocked in Butterfield Lake?

Fish stocked in Butterfield Lake average about 0.4 inches, based on the sizes the agency reported.

Do you need a fishing license to fish Butterfield Lake?

Yes, all anglers age 16 and older generally need a valid New York freshwater fishing license. Always review current regulations from New York fish & wildlife agency for site-specific rules, bag limits, or stamps.

Why do fish stocking dates or plant schedules change for Butterfield Lake?

Stocking schedules published by New York fish & wildlife agency are planned targets, not exact guarantees. Plants are frequently delayed or rescheduled due to elevated water temperatures (trout experience mortality stress above 68°F), seasonal runoff, severe weather, poor road access, or hatchery trucking logistics.